BLOG

Differentiate Between Real Marble and Fake Marble

Your kitchen countertop isn’t just a surface for preparing meals; it’s the heart of your home. It’s where homework gets done, where friends gather with a glass of wine, and where countless family memories are made. Choosing the right material is one of the most significant decisions in any renovation, and for most Alberta homeowners, it comes down to a single, crucial question. The debate over granite vs quartz countertops is the most common one we help our clients navigate. Both are fantastic, high-quality materials, but they offer very different benefits. Explore this comparison with A1 Granite & Marble, breaking down the honest pros and cons of each so you can choose with absolute confidence for your home and lifestyle.

 

The Foundation: Natural Masterpiece vs. Engineered Perfection

Every single difference between granite and quartz—from their appearance to their maintenance needs—stems from one fundamental distinction: how they are made. Understanding this core concept is the key to understanding which material is the right fit for you.

Granite: A One-of-a-Kind Masterpiece from the Earth

Granite is 100% natural stone. It’s an igneous rock, formed over millions of years as molten magma slowly cooled deep within the Earth’s crust. Composed primarily of minerals like quartz, feldspar, and mica, this stone is quarried from the earth in massive blocks. These blocks are then sliced into slabs, polished, and custom-fabricated for your home.  

Because it’s a product of nature’s powerful and unpredictable geological forces, every single slab of granite is entirely unique. The colours, the intricate veining, and the shimmering mineral deposits tell a story that is millions of years old. When you choose a granite countertop, you are installing a literal piece of the earth—a functional work of art that is truly one-of-a-kind.

Quartz: The Pinnacle of Engineered Performance and Design

In contrast, quartz countertops are an engineered, or man-made, product. They are created in a factory through a highly controlled process that combines natural materials with modern technology. The composition is typically about 90-93% crushed natural quartz crystals—one of the hardest minerals on earth—which are then bound together with 7-10% polymer resins and pigments.

This manufacturing process gives quartz some remarkable advantages. The resins fill every microscopic gap between the quartz crystals, making the final slab completely non-porous. This process also allows manufacturers to have complete control over the final appearance, resulting in a surface that is incredibly durable, consistent in colour and pattern, and available in a seemingly endless array of designs.

 

Aesthetics and Design: Choosing Your Kitchen’s Personality

Your countertop sets the tone for your entire kitchen. Are you looking for the organic drama of nature or the clean precision of modern design? This is where the visual differences between granite and quartz become a deciding factor.

The Timeless Appeal of Granite: Natural Beauty and Unique Character

Choosing granite is an embrace of nature’s artistry. Each slab offers a depth and movement that engineered products struggle to replicate. You’ll find dramatic, flowing veins, intricate flecks of colourful minerals like mica that catch the light, and a rich, organic pattern that makes the surface feel alive.

• Truly Unique: No one else in the world will have a countertop exactly like yours. Your surface is a unique “fingerprint” of the earth, adding bespoke character to your home.  
• A Spectrum of Natural Colours: Granite comes in a stunning range of colours, from warm, earthy golds and browns to deep blacks, cool greys, and even exotic blues, greens, and reds.
• Design Consideration: This natural variation means that seams between slabs can be more noticeable, and it requires careful planning for larger kitchens to ensure a cohesive look.  

The Versatile Palette of Quartz: Consistency, Control, and Modern Style

Quartz is the ultimate design chameleon. Because it’s engineered, the aesthetic possibilities are nearly limitless, making it a powerful tool for achieving a specific vision. It perfectly serves modern design trends that favour clean lines and uniformity.

• Unmatched Consistency: If you want a countertop that is uniform in colour and pattern from one end to the other, quartz is the clear winner. This consistency makes seams nearly invisible, which is ideal for large islands, waterfall edges, and complex layouts.
• Endless Colour Options: From brilliant, solid whites and subtle greys to bold, dramatic blacks and vibrant colours not found in nature, quartz offers a massive palette to choose from.  
• The Marble Look, Without the Worry: Many homeowners love the elegant look of white marble but are concerned about its softness and susceptibility to staining. Quartz manufacturers have perfected designs that beautifully mimic the look of Carrara or Calacatta marble, offering that classic aesthetic with superior durability and zero maintenance worries.  

 

The Durability Deep Dive: How Do They Stand Up to Real Life?

The word “durability” gets used a lot, but what does it actually mean for your daily life? Break down the durability pros and cons of granite and quartz in the areas that matter most in a busy Alberta kitchen with A1 Granite & Marble.

Heat Resistance: The Passionate Cook’s Deciding Factor

This is one of the most significant differences between the two materials.

• Granite: As a stone born from incredible heat and pressure, granite is exceptionally resistant to high temperatures. You can take a hot pot or pan straight from the oven or stovetop and place it directly on your granite countertop without any fear of scorching, burning, or cracking. It can withstand heat up to approximately 650°C (1200°F).  
• Quartz: The polymer resins in quartz are its point of vulnerability when it comes to heat. While it is heat-resistant, it is not heat-proof. High heat from a hot pan (typically above 150°C or 300°F) can cause the resin to scorch, leaving a permanent discoloured mark, or even cause “thermal shock,” which can crack the surface. For this reason, you must always use trivets or hot pads with quartz countertops.

Scratches and Chips: The Test of Daily Wear and Tear

Both granite and quartz are incredibly hard materials, making them highly resistant to scratches.

• Scratch Resistance: On the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, granite scores a 6-7, while engineered quartz scores around a 7. This means both surfaces are very difficult to scratch with everyday items like knives or utensils. However, we always recommend using a cutting board to protect the sharp edge of your knives.
• Impact Resistance: Both materials are very strong, but there is a slight nuance. The resins in quartz give it a tiny amount of flexibility. This can make it slightly more resistant to chipping if a heavy object is dropped on it. Granite is more rigid and can be more prone to chipping or cracking from a severe impact, especially at the edges or around the sink. That said, repairs to a chip in granite can often be blended more seamlessly due to the natural patterns and depth of the stone.

Stains and Spills: The Porosity Question

This is perhaps the most important practical difference in day-to-day living.

• Quartz: Thanks to the manufacturing process, quartz is completely non-porous. The resins bind the quartz crystals into a seamless, solid surface with no microscopic holes. This means liquids like red wine, coffee, oil, or juice cannot penetrate the surface and cause a stain. This non-porous nature also makes it highly hygienic, as there is nowhere for bacteria, mold, or mildew to hide.
• Granite: As a natural stone, granite is porous. It has tiny, microscopic channels between the mineral crystals. If a spill sits on an unsealed or poorly sealed granite countertop, the liquid can seep into the pores and potentially cause a stain. The solution to this is simple and effective: sealing.  

 

The Reality of Maintenance: What Does It Really Take?

The topic of maintenance is often where myths and misconceptions cloud the granite vs. quartz debate. The reality is much simpler than you might think.

The “Set It and Forget It” Appeal of Quartz

If your top priority is the absolute lowest maintenance possible, quartz is your answer.

• No Sealing Required: Because it is non-porous, a quartz countertop never needs to be sealed. Ever.  
• Simple Daily Cleaning: For everyday cleaning, all you need is a soft cloth with mild soap and warm water. It’s important to avoid abrasive scrubbers or harsh chemical cleaners (like bleach or oven cleaner), as they can dull the polished surface over time.  

Demystifying Granite Sealing: A Simple Task for Lasting Protection

Granite has a reputation for being “high-maintenance,” but this is largely outdated. While it does require sealing, the process with modern sealers is incredibly simple.

• What is Sealing? A sealer is a liquid that penetrates the pores of the granite and creates an invisible barrier, preventing spills from soaking in.  
• How Often? With today’s high-quality sealers, most kitchen countertops only need to be resealed about once a year, and some advanced sealers can last even longer.  
• How Is It Done? The process is a simple DIY task that takes about 15 minutes. You simply spray or wipe the sealer on, let it absorb for a few minutes, and then wipe off any excess. It’s no more difficult than cleaning your windows. This small act of care protects your beautiful, natural investment for years to come.
• Daily Cleaning: Like quartz, daily cleaning is easy. Use a pH-neutral cleaner designed for stone or just mild dish soap and water. Avoid acidic cleaners like vinegar or lemon juice, as they can wear down the sealer more quickly.  

 

Making the Right Choice for Your Alberta Home and Lifestyle

So, after comparing all the pros and cons, which stone is the winner? The truth is, there isn’t one. The best countertop is the one that fits your life. Let’s make it simple.

Choose Granite If…

• You are a passionate home cook. You value the peace of mind that comes with exceptional heat resistance and want the freedom to move hot pans without constantly reaching for a trivet.  
• You love truly unique, natural beauty. You want a one-of-a-kind statement countertop with organic movement, depth, and character that no one can replicate.
• You are planning an outdoor kitchen. Granite is naturally resistant to UV rays and will not fade or discolour in direct sunlight, making it the only suitable choice for outdoor applications.
• You appreciate the timeless value of natural materials. You see your countertop as a long-term investment in a material that people have prized for its beauty and strength for centuries.

Choose Quartz If…

• You have a busy family and need zero-maintenance. Your top priority is a worry-free surface that is virtually stain-proof, never needs sealing, and is incredibly easy to clean up after spills.  
• You desire a specific, consistent look. You have a modern design vision that requires a solid white, a bold uniform colour, or a predictable pattern for a seamless aesthetic.  
• Hygiene is a top concern. The non-porous surface that resists bacteria growth gives you the ultimate peace of mind for food preparation in your kitchen and cleanliness in your bathroom.  
• You love the look of marble without the worry. You want that classic, elegant marble aesthetic but need a surface that can stand up to the demands of a busy household without chipping, staining, or etching.  

 

Still Unsure? Let’s Talk It Through.

A1 Granite & Marble knows that even with all this information, choosing between these two incredible materials can be a challenge. Both granite and quartz are premium choices that will add beauty, function, and significant value to your home. The best decision always comes down to your personal priorities, your design goals, and how you live your life every day. This is where personalized, expert advice makes all the difference. Our team isn’t here to sell you a slab of stone; we’re here to be your trusted partner in creating the home you’ve always wanted.

Confused about which stone is right for you? Talk to our experts at A1 Granite & Marble. Schedule a free consultation.